About this Resource
Productive reading
Writing effectively
Who are you trying to convince?
Putting yourself in your assessor’s place
Identifying explicit criteria underlying audience feedback
Looking for feedback on what you are doing well and what needs improving
Feedback prompt list: reinforcing the good and avoiding the weak
Identifying the implicit criteria underlying audience feedback
Expanding what you learn from audience feedback
Familiarising yourself with the official criteria for assessment
Learning systematically from audience feedback
Learning from your writing for formative and summative assessment
Formative and summative assessment in writing for academic presentation
Criteria for academic presentation and developing a convincing argument
Comparing criteria for academic publication and assessing students’ work
Who needs convincing if your work is to get published in an academic journal?
Inside an academic journal editor’s world
Getting to grips with academic journal criteria for acceptance
Building your sense of audience: an interview with a journal editor
Top tips for postgraduate and doctoral research students who aspire to get published
Arguing convincingly
Mapping your field
Literature reviewing
Reviewing the literature systematically
Developing proposals

Learning systematically from audience feeback - our answer

Our answer is that this specific criterion of good practice relates most closely to part of Criterion 2: students must demonstrate that they have understood current theories. To do this, they should demonstrate that they know the key concepts of the particular theories they write about for assessment.

So, in the table below, you could list this criterion of good practice in the lefthand column, and the criterion for assessment that it relates most closely to in the adjacent righthand column.

Every time you receive feedback on your writing for assessment you could add to this list, so you gradually build-up a profile of the specific criteria of good practice that relate to each of the more general criteria for assessment.

 

Criterion of good practice derived from feedback on my writing for assessment

How does the criterion of good practice relate to the official criteria for assessment?

1

 

 

2

 

 

3

 

 

4

 

 

5

 

 

6

 

 

7

 

 

8

 

 

9

 

 

10

 

 

You could keep the growing list as a file on your computer that you add to every time you identify a new criterion of good practice.

Download the form here 

function SD06736D6_Submit() { GoSearch(null, 'ctl00_PlaceHolderSearchArea_SearchBox_SD06736D6_InputKeywords', null, true, false, null, null, null, null, 'Learningsystematicallyfromaudiencefeedbackanswer.html\u002f\u002fwww.networkedcranfield.com\u002flogicofenquiry\u002fgst\u002fWriting\u002f_layouts\u002fOSSSearchResults.aspx', 'This Site', 'This List', 'This Folder', 'Related Sites', '\u002flogicofenquiry\u002fgst\u002fWriting\u002f_layouts\u002fOSSSearchResults.aspx'); } // -->